Instrument
Trust Premium Score
The Trust Premium Score measures how much value an organization earns from AI that people trust, across 15 dimensions in three pillars: risk avoided, performance gained and market value earned. Each dimension is scored from 1 to 5 on what runs today, so the total falls between 15 and 75 and places the organization in one of four bands.
Last verified
Scoring
| Dimension | Score 1 | Score 3 | Score 5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pillar 1: Risk avoided (the floor) | |||
| 1.1 Regulatory readiness | Score 1No regulatory tracking; AI ships without legal review. | Score 3Regulation tracked in key jurisdictions; legal review before deployment. | Score 5Compliance infrastructure reused across jurisdictions; the organization helps shape policy. |
| 1.2 Incident preparedness | Score 1Customers or the press find AI failures; no post-incident process. | Score 3Incident classes, a response playbook and reviews for high-severity events. | Score 5Preventive design keeps incidents rare; response is rehearsed and lessons are shared. |
| 1.3 Governance maturity | Score 1No governance structure; whoever has access deploys AI. | Score 3Named owners, an AI system inventory, risk tiers and deployment gates. | Score 5Board-level reporting; governance makes deployment faster, not slower. |
| 1.4 Data protection | Score 1Training data provenance unknown; shadow AI reaches uncontrolled data. | Score 3Documented provenance, tracked consent, privacy impact assessments for new systems. | Score 5Privacy by design in the AI architecture; data governance enables new work. |
| 1.5 Compliance readiness | Score 1No documentation of AI systems or decisions; a regulator’s question could not be answered. | Score 3Standard model documentation for every production system, with audit trails. | Score 5Continuous compliance monitoring; any regulatory inquiry answered within 48 hours. |
| Pillar 2: Performance gained (the engine) | |||
| 2.1 AI adoption rate | Score 1AI confined to one team or pilot; shadow AI exceeds sanctioned use. | Score 3AI in three to five core functions under coordinated governance. | Score 5AI is a core operating capability across the organization. |
| 2.2 Deployment velocity | Score 1Projects take 12 months or more; most pilots never ship. | Score 3Three to six months to production, with governance checkpoints set up front. | Score 5Governance as code; low-risk models reach production in days. |
| 2.3 Model reliability | Score 1Production performance unmonitored; users find the failures. | Score 3Baselines for every production model, regular monitoring and drift detection. | Score 5Automated quality checks; performance data feeds back into the standards. |
| 2.4 Cross-functional trust | Score 1Business leaders distrust AI outputs and verify every decision by hand. | Score 3Legal, risk and business owners help design and review AI systems. | Score 5AI-informed decisions are the default; human override is the exception. |
| 2.5 Innovation velocity | Score 1No route for experiments; each new idea waits months for approval. | Score 3Light-governance sandboxes with clear criteria for moving to production. | Score 5A steady pipeline of experiments, known in the industry for speed and care. |
| Pillar 3: Market value earned (the moat) | |||
| 3.1 Customer trust perception | Score 1Customers distrust the organization’s AI; opt-out rates are high. | Score 3AI practices explained to customers; customer trust measured quarterly. | Score 5Customers share data willingly because they trust its stewardship. |
| 3.2 Brand differentiation | Score 1No trust positioning, or claims that practice contradicts (ethics washing). | Score 3Published principles, governance documentation or third-party certification. | Score 5The organization sets its industry’s standard; competitors benchmark against it. |
| 3.3 Talent attraction | Score 1AI talent avoids the organization; turnover runs above average. | Score 3Governance is part of the employer brand; candidates ask about it. | Score 5A destination employer for AI talent because of its trust record. |
| 3.4 Partner ecosystem | Score 1Partners will not share data or co-develop because of governance gaps. | Score 3Governance maturity supports standard data-sharing agreements. | Score 5Partners join to reach the governed data and AI infrastructure. |
| 3.5 Investor confidence | Score 1Investors see AI as unmanaged risk; gaps show up in due diligence. | Score 3The board has a defined AI oversight mechanism with regular reporting. | Score 5Analysts cite AI governance as a strategic asset of the company. |
Score each dimension from 1 to 5 on evidence of what operates today, not on plans. A policy nobody enforces scores the same as no policy. Add the five scores in each pillar (5 to 25), then add the three pillars for the total (15 to 75). Scores of 2 and 4 sit between the descriptions.
| Total | Band | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| 15-25 | BandTrust Deficit | What it meansAI is a liability. Build the floor first: an AI system inventory, a named owner for each system and an estimate of the Pillar 1 exposure. |
| 26-45 | BandTrust Neutral | What it meansCompliant, with no advantage from trust yet. Fix the weakest dimension in each pillar and start measuring what trust work changes in deployment speed and adoption. |
| 46-60 | BandTrust Positive | What it meansTrust is paying back. Push Pillar 2 and 3 dimensions in the highest-value AI system and use governance maturity to win partnerships. |
| 61-75 | BandTrust Premium Leader | What it meansTrust is a moat. Red-team the trust infrastructure for single points of failure and report the premium to the board with hard numbers. |
Download: Trust Premium Assessment Worksheet
The printable worksheet: every dimension, the score bands and room for your team's evidence.
Enter your email to get instant access. You'll also get The Brief, every other Tuesday.
Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Why this instrument exists, and what the scores mean for a leadership team: Trust Is the Most Underpriced Variable in Enterprise AI
Reading the score
Score as a cross-functional team: technology, legal, risk and the business. A single function scoring itself tends to score high.
Then read two things. The band says where the organization stands. The pillar balance says what kind of problem it has. Two organizations can both total 50: one at 22, 15 and 13 has protected itself but captures little value, while one at 12, 20 and 18 captures value on an exposed floor. A Trust Premium Leader scores 20 or more on every pillar, not 25 on one and 12 on another.
After scoring, apply the Family Test. Would you trust this organization’s AI with your family’s financial data (Pillar 1)? Would you rely on it for a decision about your family’s health (Pillar 2)? Would you recommend its AI products to your family (Pillar 3)? If the score says adequate and the answer is no, rescore.
The 90-Day Trust Sprint
A score without a plan is an audit. The sprint turns it into a quarter of work, in the spirit of Minimum Viable Governance: start with the smallest structure that works and mature it through practice.
Weeks 1 to 2: audit
Fill in the worksheet with the cross-functional team. Record the band and the three weakest dimensions. In Trust Deficit, also build the AI system inventory, because nobody can govern what they cannot see.
Weeks 3 to 4: prioritize
Pick three dimensions to move. In Trust Deficit, take them from Pillar 1, since the floor has to hold first. In Trust Neutral, take the weakest dimension in each pillar. In Trust Positive, take the Pillar 2 and 3 dimensions that speed up adoption and set the organization apart.
Weeks 5 to 8: implement
Give each chosen dimension a target one level up, such as from 2 to 3. The rubric is the plan: each level describes what has to be documented, made routine or owned.
- Trust Deficit: finish the AI inventory, name a governance owner for each system, estimate the Pillar 1 exposure, draft the incident playbook and run the Family Test on every production system.
- Trust Neutral: put governance checks into the deployment pipeline, automate checks for low-risk systems, start counting incidents avoided and time saved, and launch AI literacy training.
- Trust Positive: run the trust and adoption loop on the highest-value AI system, use governance maturity to secure a partnership and publish the governance practices.
- Trust Premium Leader: red-team the trust infrastructure, take part in standard-setting and report the premium to the board.
Weeks 9 to 12: measure
Rescore all 15 dimensions and track the change. The aim is the next band, not the highest number, because each band opens different options: leaving Trust Deficit stops the losses, and reaching Trust Positive starts the payback.
| Industry | What raises the bar | Pillar 1 | Pillar 2 | Pillar 3 | Leader total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Financial services | What raises the barCredit, fraud and trading models carry AI-specific rules | Pillar 1Above 22 | Pillar 2Above 20 | Pillar 3Above 19 | Leader totalAbove 61 |
| Healthcare | What raises the barLife-safety stakes and clinical validation | Pillar 1Above 23 | Pillar 2Above 19 | Pillar 3Above 18 | Leader totalAbove 60 |
| Government | What raises the barPublic accountability; failures become political events | Pillar 1Above 22 | Pillar 2Above 18 | Pillar 3Above 17 | Leader totalAbove 57 |
| Consumer technology | What raises the barBrand sensitivity; trust failures and wins spread fastest | Pillar 1Above 20 | Pillar 2Above 22 | Pillar 3Above 21 | Leader totalAbove 63 |
These thresholds are the framework’s own calibration from each sector’s regulatory pressure and trust sensitivity, not survey data. Use them to read a score in context, not to excuse it.
| Finding | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| What broken trust costs (Pillar 1) | ||
| Maximum EU AI Act fine for a prohibited AI practice; other listed obligations, transparency included, carry up to EUR 15 million or 3%. Fines apply from 2 August 2025 | FigureUp to EUR 35 million or 7% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher | SourceRegulation (EU) 2024/1689, Article 99 |
| Extra breach cost at organizations with high use of unsanctioned (shadow) AI, against low or none | Figure$670,000 per breach ($4.74 million against $4.07 million) | SourceIBM, Cost of a Data Breach Report 2025 |
| Organizations reporting a breach of their AI models or applications, and the share of those without AI access controls | Figure13%, of which 97% had no AI access controls | SourceIBM, Cost of a Data Breach Report 2025 |
| AI-related incidents reported to the AI Incident Database in 2024 | Figure233, up 56.4% on 2023 | SourceStanford HAI, AI Index 2025 |
| AI-related securities class action filings in the US | Figure7 in 2023, 15 in 2024 | SourceCornerstone Research, Securities Class Action Filings: 2024 Year in Review |
| Australia’s Robodebt scheme: money refunded to people and debts written off after the automated debt-raising was found unlawful | FigureA$746 million refunded to about 381,000 people; A$1.751 billion in debts written off | SourceRoyal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme, Report, 2023 |
| What earned trust returns (Pillar 2) | ||
| Operating profit attributable to AI at organizations spending 10% or more of their AI budget on ethics, against those spending 5% or less (average over two years; a correlation) | Figure30% higher | SourceIBM Institute for Business Value, The AI ethics trust engine, 2025 (915 executives) |
| Self-reported improvement over 12 months among organizations investing in AI ethics: customer satisfaction and retention, AI ethics incident prevention, AI adoption | Figure+22%, +20%, +19% | SourceIBM Institute for Business Value, The AI ethics trust engine, 2025 |
| US business leaders who say responsible AI boosts ROI and efficiency; who report better customer experience and innovation | Figure58%; 55% | SourcePwC, 2025 US Responsible AI Survey (310 leaders) |
| What demonstrated trust is worth (Pillar 3) | ||
| Return on equity of companies whose boards are both digitally and AI savvy, against industry average (non-savvy boards: 3.8 points below) | Figure10.9 percentage points above | SourceMIT CISR, Digitally Savvy Boards: AI Update, 2025 |
| Boards that were both digitally and AI savvy in 2024 | Figure26% | SourceMIT CISR, Digitally Savvy Boards: AI Update, 2025 |
| People who say they trust AI, across 28 markets; in the US; in China | Figure49%; 32%; 72% | SourceEdelman Trust Barometer 2025 |
The return and value figures are correlations: organizations that invest in trust may also be better run. Read them as a consistent direction across independent sources, not as proof of cause.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (Artificial Intelligence Act), Articles 99 and 113. Official Journal of the European Union, 2024-07-12
- Cost of a Data Breach Report 2025: The AI Oversight Gap. IBM and Ponemon Institute, 2025-07-30
- IBM Report: 13% of organizations reported breaches of AI models or applications, 97% of which reported lacking proper AI access controls. IBM Newsroom, 2025-07-30
- The AI Index 2025 Annual Report, Responsible AI chapter. Stanford HAI, 2025
- Securities Class Action Filings: 2024 Year in Review. Cornerstone Research, 2025-01
- Report of the Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme. Commonwealth of Australia, 2023-07-07
- The AI ethics trust engine. IBM Institute for Business Value with the Notre Dame-IBM Technology Ethics Lab, 2025
- 2025 US Responsible AI Survey. PwC, 2025
- Digitally Savvy Boards: AI Update, Research Briefing XXV-3. MIT Center for Information Systems Research, 2025-03-20
- 2025 Edelman Trust Barometer: Insights for the Technology Sector. Edelman, 2025-02
- The AI Trust Imperative. Edelman, 2025-02-13
Ajay's views, from fifteen-plus years in the field. Not legal or compliance advice. See full disclaimers →
Published by AI Exponent LLC